Reviewed by Michael Dalton
From the minute word got out that M. Night Shyamalan was to direct After
Earth, a sci-fi “extravaganza”, and that he had cast Will Smith and his son
Jaden, the critics and bloggers of the world were sharpening their keyboards in
readiness. In this supreme exercise in nepotism, Shyamalan’s track record
precedes him but is it really that bad? Unsurprisingly, the always honest
Tomatometer commenced measurements in the low teens with slaps like “incredible
boredom…abysmal acting”, “disappointing” and “lack of ambition”. The fact is,
the only way this director, now a punchline, was going to shake off The
Happening, Lady In The Water, and The Last Airbender was to deliver unto us a
masterpiece. After Earth is neither a good film, nor a bad one. Furnished with
primitive CGI, there are unintentionally funny moments, yet it remains an
ordinary, formulaic adventure that often resembles a video game.
